Dive into this comprehensive guide tailored for Class 12 students, covering The Cutting of My Long Hair and We Too Are Human Beings from Memories of Childhood. This post features detailed summaries, thematic analyses, extract-based MCQs, and subjective questions with answers to help students excel in board exams and periodic tests. Discover the stories’ powerful themes of cultural oppression, identity, and resilience, and sharpen your understanding through expertly crafted practice questions and insights.
- Summary of The Cutting of My Long Hair – Memories of Childhood
- Summary of Bama’s ‘We Too Are Human Being ‘ – Memories of Childhood
- Themes of Oppression and Identity in The Cutting of My Long Hair and We Too Are Human Beings
- Explanation of Memories of Childhood
- Reading with Insight (Q&A of The Cutting of My Long Hair)
- Extract-Based MCQs from The Cutting of My Long Hair
- Extract-Based MCQs from We Too Are Human Beings
- Important Questions from Memories of Childhood
Summary of The Cutting of My Long Hair – Memories of Childhood
Summary:
In The Cutting of My Long Hair, Zitkala-Sa, a Native American girl, recounts her first day at a boarding school designed to assimilate Indigenous children into Western culture. The harshness of the environment is palpable, from the cacophony of noises to the regimented dining hall rules. The most significant moment of the story is when Zitkala-Sa learns that her hair, symbolic of her heritage and dignity, will be forcibly cut. Despite feeling isolated and powerless, she rebels, hiding to protect this last link to her identity. Her resistance is crushed when she is found and restrained, leading to the shingling of her hair. This act is a symbol of submission forced upon her, capturing her anguish and loss of spirit as she is stripped of autonomy and cultural pride.
Summary of Bama’s ‘We Too Are Human Being ‘ – Memories of Childhood
Summary:
In We Too Are Human Beings, Bama, a young girl from a Tamil Dalit community, describes her early experiences of caste discrimination. While returning home from school, she is captivated by the sights and sounds of her village, each detail brimming with life. However, the scene shifts when she witnesses an elder from her community delivering snacks to an upper-caste landlord with exaggerated reverence, avoiding any direct contact. This moment stirs an awakening in Bama as her brother explains the degrading rules imposed by the caste system. Fueled by anger and a newfound awareness, she channels her resolve into excelling at school, recognising education as a pathway to dignity and empowerment. The story is a powerful testament to how observation of everyday injustices can ignite the desire for change.
Themes of Oppression and Identity in The Cutting of My Long Hair and We Too Are Human Beings
Both stories, The Cutting of My Long Hair by Zitkala-Sa and We Too Are Human Beings by Bama, share the common theme of systemic oppression and the struggle for identity within marginalised communities. Although their cultural contexts are different—Native American in the former and Tamil Dalit in the latter—their experiences resonate with shared elements of resistance, loss, and the pursuit of dignity.
Theme of Oppression:
Both narratives highlight the pervasive nature of discrimination and the way it is imposed on children, seeding trauma from an early age. Zitkala-Sa’s account exposes the brutal attempt to erase Native American heritage through forced assimilation. The cutting of her hair, a deeply symbolic act, represents a violation of her identity and autonomy. This imposed cultural conformity strips her of personal and communal pride, showcasing the systematic attempts to suppress her people’s heritage.
Similarly, Bama’s story sheds light on the rigid social hierarchy entrenched in the caste system. The scene where she observes an elder carrying food for an upper-caste man, avoiding direct contact to prevent “pollution,” starkly illustrates the insidious nature of caste discrimination. This moment unveils the humiliating servitude expected of her community, despite their shared humanity.
Theme of Identity and Resistance:
Both protagonists experience a turning point where they recognise the injustice around them and instinctively resist it. Zitkala-Sa’s desperate act of hiding to avoid having her hair cut shows an innate drive to protect her identity, even when faced with overwhelming power. Her struggle reflects the universal yearning to hold on to one’s roots and resist cultural erasure.
Bama’s reaction to witnessing the elder’s subservience transitions from amusement to deep anger when her brother explains the discriminatory practice. Her response is not passive; it fuels her determination to excel in her studies as a form of protest. For her, education becomes a tool to defy societal constraints and reclaim her sense of worth, emphasising that rebellion often begins with a shift in perception.
Conclusion:
Both stories(from the chapter Memories of Childhood) illuminate how marginalised individuals, even as children, are acutely aware of injustice. They show that the seeds of resistance are planted early, manifesting in acts of defiance, however small. Zitkala-Sa and Bama’s stories are powerful reminders that the fight for dignity and identity begins within the individual and that awareness is the precursor to change.
Explanation of Memories of Childhood
The Cutting of My Long Hair – A Story of Cultural Loss and Silent Rebellion
Explanation:
The Cutting of My Long Hair(from the chapter Memories of Childhood) by Zitkala-Sa narrates a young Native American girl’s harrowing experience at a boarding school where assimilation policies are enforced to erase Indigenous identity. The story opens with Zitkala-Sa facing an unfamiliar, cold environment full of harsh, jarring noises. The climax arrives when she learns that her long hair, a cherished part of her culture symbolising pride and identity, will be cut—a practice associated with humiliation among her people. Despite the fear and pressure, Zitkala-Sa rebels by hiding, attempting to preserve her dignity. However, she is found, dragged out, and forcibly shorn. This act is emblematic of cultural domination and loss of freedom, leaving her spirit subdued. The story captures the trauma of cultural erasure and the quiet resistance that marks the beginning of a lifelong fight for identity.
We Too Are Human Beings – A Child’s Awakening to Caste Injustice
Explanation:
We Too Are Human Beings(from the chapter Memories of Childhood) by Bama reveals a young Tamil Dalit girl’s growing awareness of caste discrimination in her village. The narrative unfolds as Bama walks home from school, enchanted by the vibrant scenes of street life. However, her carefree observations are shattered when she sees an elder from her community carrying food to an upper-caste landlord with exaggerated respect, holding the parcel by its string to avoid direct contact. This moment strikes her as absurd until her brother explains it as a sign of caste-based subjugation. The realisation sparks both sadness and anger in Bama, fuelling her resolve to study hard and break free from these societal constraints. The story underscores how a child’s awareness of injustice can grow into a powerful drive for change, portraying education as a pathway to reclaiming dignity and challenging entrenched social norms.
Reading with Insight (Q&A of The Cutting of My Long Hair)
1. The two accounts that you read above are based in two distant cultures. What is the commonality of theme found in both of them?
Short Answer Type:
Despite their origins in different cultures, the common theme in both narratives is the experience of oppression and the profound effect it has on the individual. Both Zitkala-Sa and Bama recount their childhood struggles against the societal discrimination imposed upon them, highlighting the pain of marginalisation and the resilience they draw from these early experiences.
2. It may take a long time for oppression to be resisted, but the seeds of rebellion are sowed early in life. Do you agree that injustice in any form cannot escape being noticed even by children?
Long Answer Type:
Yes, I agree that even children, with their keen sense of right and wrong, can notice and feel the sting of injustice. This is evident in the accounts of both Zitkala-Sa and Bama. Zitkala-Sa’s story reveals her deep awareness of the indignities imposed by cultural assimilation, and she instinctively fights against having her hair cut—a symbol of her identity. Similarly, Bama’s childhood observations of caste discrimination stir frustration and sadness within her, planting seeds of awareness and defiance. These early moments are significant; they set the foundation for future acts of resistance and the pursuit of dignity.
3. Bama’s experience is that of a victim of the caste system. What kind of discrimination does Zitkala-Sa’s experience depict? What are their responses to their respective situations?
Short Answer Type:
Zitkala-Sa’s experience depicts racial and cultural discrimination against Native Americans. While Bama feels anger and determination after witnessing caste-based discrimination, Zitkala-Sa responds with defiance, seeking to preserve her sense of identity even when forcibly subdued.
Extract-Based MCQs from The Cutting of My Long Hair
Extract 1:
“The first day in the land of apples was a bitter-cold one; for the snow still covered the ground, and the trees were bare. A large bell rang for breakfast, its loud metallic voice crashing through the belfry overhead and into our sensitive ears.”
Questions:
- What does “the land of apples” refer to in the context of the story?
- a) Zitkala-Sa’s homeland
- b) A metaphor for the school
- c) A fruit orchard
- d) A distant town
- The sound of the large bell symbolises:
- a) Celebration and joy
- b) Harshness and control
- c) Calmness and peace
- d) Disorganisation and chaos
- What feeling does Zitkala-Sa express when describing the bell’s sound?
- a) Comfort
- b) Indifference
- c) Discomfort
- d) Curiosity
Extract 2:
“I crept up the stairs as quietly as I could in my squeaking shoes, — my moccasins had been exchanged for shoes. Along the hall I passed, without knowing whither I was going. Turning aside to an open door, I found a large room with three white beds in it.”
Questions:
- Why does Zitkala-Sa move so quietly up the stairs?
- a) She is playing a game.
- b) She is trying to escape being found.
- c) She is exploring the school.
- d) She is searching for a friend.
- The change from moccasins to shoes symbolises:
- a) Adaptation and comfort
- b) Freedom and expression
- c) Loss of cultural identity
- d) Wealth and status
- What does the room with white beds represent for Zitkala-Sa at this moment?
- a) A place of hope
- b) A temporary hiding spot
- c) A welcoming area
- d) A familiar space
Extract 3:
“I cried aloud, shaking my head all the while until I felt the cold blades of the scissors against my neck, and heard them gnaw off one of my thick braids. Then I lost my spirit.”
Questions:
- The act of cutting Zitkala-Sa’s hair is symbolic of:
- a) A new fashion trend
- b) The acceptance of a new culture
- c) The erasure of her Native identity
- d) A rite of passage
- How does Zitkala-Sa react during the cutting of her hair?
- a) With silent acceptance
- b) By cheering
- c) With active resistance and crying
- d) By laughing
- The phrase “Then I lost my spirit” suggests:
- a) She felt stronger afterward
- b) She found peace within
- c) Her emotional defeat and despair
- d) Her excitement for change
Extract-Based MCQs from We Too Are Human Beings
Extract 4:
“I was walking home from school one day, an old bag hanging from my shoulder. It was actually possible to walk the distance in ten minutes. But usually it would take me thirty minutes at the very least to reach home.”
Questions:
- Why did it take Bama longer to reach home?
- a) She walked slowly out of exhaustion.
- b) She was captivated by the sights and activities along the way.
- c) She met friends and talked with them.
- d) She was afraid of going home.
- The description of Bama’s walk suggests her:
- a) Enthusiasm for school
- b) Interest in the world around her
- c) Frustration with her community
- d) Urgency to reach home
- What does the old bag on Bama’s shoulder symbolise?
- a) Her wealth
- b) Her curiosity
- c) Her socio-economic status
- d) Her pride
Extract 5:
“The elder went straight up to the landlord, bowed low and extended the packet towards him, cupping the hand that held the string with his other hand. The landlord opened the parcel and began to eat the vadais.”
Questions:
- The elder’s gesture of bowing low signifies:
- a) Pride and strength
- b) Humour and playfulness
- c) Submission and respect imposed by caste norms
- d) Anger and defiance
- Why did the elder hold the packet by its string?
- a) To protect the food from dirt
- b) To avoid touching it due to caste restrictions
- c) To show off the snacks
- d) To make it easier to carry
- The landlord’s act of eating the vadais symbolises:
- a) A shared meal between equals
- b) The exploitation of caste hierarchy
- c) Generosity towards the elder
- d) Celebration of tradition
Extract 6:
“Annan told me the man wasn’t being funny when he carried the package like that. He said everybody believed that they were upper caste and therefore must not touch us. If they did, they would be polluted.”
Questions:
- What emotion does Bama feel after hearing her brother’s explanation?
- a) Joy
- b) Sadness and anger
- c) Amusement
- d) Indifference
- The concept of “pollution” in the context refers to:
- a) Environmental cleanliness
- b) Religious belief
- c) The caste system’s discriminatory practices
- d) Food hygiene
- Annan’s explanation makes Bama:
- a) Feel content and accepted
- b) Laugh at the absurdity of the rules
- c) More determined to work hard and fight discrimination
- d) Want to leave her community
Answer Key:
Extract 1:
- b) A metaphor for the school
- b) Harshness and control
- c) Discomfort
Extract 2:
- b) She is trying to escape being found.
- c) Loss of cultural identity
- b) A temporary hiding spot
Extract 3:
- c) The erasure of her Native identity
- c) With active resistance and crying
- c) Her emotional defeat and despair
Extract 4:
- b) She was captivated by the sights and activities along the way.
- b) Interest in the world around her
- c) Her socio-economic status
Extract 5:
- c) Submission and respect imposed by caste norms
- b) To avoid touching it due to caste restrictions
- b) The exploitation of caste hierarchy
Extract 6:
- b) Sadness and anger
- c) The caste system’s discriminatory practices
- c) More determined to work hard and fight discrimination
Important Questions from Memories of Childhood
Questions from The Cutting of My Long Hair
1. What does the act of cutting Zitkala-Sa’s hair symbolise in the story, and why does it affect her so deeply?
Short Answer Type:
The cutting of Zitkala-Sa’s hair symbolises the erasure of her cultural identity and submission to enforced assimilation. For her, hair is not just a physical trait but a symbol of pride and connection to her heritage, making the act deeply distressing.
2. How does Zitkala-Sa demonstrate resistance in the face of cultural suppression?
Short Answer Type:
Zitkala-Sa resists cultural suppression by hiding to avoid having her hair cut. This act, though ultimately unsuccessful, shows her strong will to protect her identity and resist the loss of her cultural symbols.
3. Explain the significance of the setting in the story. How does it contribute to Zitkala-Sa’s feeling of alienation?
Long Answer Type:
The setting—a strict, unfamiliar boarding school with cold surroundings and constant harsh noises—amplifies Zitkala-Sa’s feeling of alienation. The regimented environment and the impersonal treatment reflect the broader theme of oppression and cultural domination. These elements highlight her displacement and lack of freedom, reinforcing the story’s central tension between the forced assimilation and her internal fight for identity.
4. What emotions does Zitkala-Sa go through during her first day at the school, and how are they conveyed through her narrative?
Short Answer Type:
Zitkala-Sa experiences fear, discomfort, confusion, defiance, and ultimately despair. These emotions are conveyed through vivid descriptions of her sensory experiences and reactions, such as the clanging bell, the awkward dining ritual, and the traumatic cutting of her hair.
5. Why does Zitkala-Sa say she “lost her spirit” after her hair was cut? What does this moment signify?
Very Short Answer Type:
She says she “lost her spirit” because the forced cutting of her hair symbolised a defeat of her personal and cultural identity. This moment signifies the crushing impact of assimilation on her self-worth and heritage.
Questions from We Too Are Human Beings
6. What triggers Bama’s awareness of caste discrimination, and how does this realisation affect her?
Short Answer Type:
Bama becomes aware of caste discrimination when she sees an elder carrying food for an upper-caste landlord in a subservient manner. This realisation stirs feelings of anger and sadness, leading her to resolve to study hard and overcome social barriers.
7. Discuss the role of Bama’s brother, Annan, in shaping her response to the caste system.
Short Answer Type:
Annan plays a pivotal role by explaining the harsh realities of the caste system and encouraging Bama to focus on education as a means to rise above discrimination. His advice motivates her to channel her frustration into academic excellence and personal empowerment.
8. How does the author use everyday scenes and observations to highlight the caste system’s impact on the community?
Long Answer Type:
The author uses detailed descriptions of mundane activities—like the elder carrying food for the landlord—to illustrate the deep-rooted nature of caste discrimination. By focusing on ordinary moments that subtly reinforce social hierarchy, the story reveals how such injustices permeate daily life. This approach allows readers to grasp the normalised nature of the caste system and its quiet yet profound impact on individuals like Bama.
9. What does Bama’s walk home from school reveal about her character and perspective on life?
Short Answer Type:
Bama’s leisurely walk home, filled with fascination for the activities around her, reveals her curiosity and youthful spirit. It also highlights her observant nature, which later becomes crucial when she recognises the caste-based inequality in her community.
10. How does the story We Too Are Human Beings illustrate the transformative power of education?
Very Short Answer Type:
The story illustrates that education empowers individuals to challenge societal norms and seek respect. For Bama, studying hard is not just about academic success but about reclaiming dignity and defying the caste system’s limitations.
Pingback: Class 12 Vistas: Chapter-wise Notes and Explanations for Exam Prep! - Solved Notes